Bubbles, Reflections and Space Walks… Did China Really Fake It?

Tracks of seven objects during Chinese space walk. Red tracks are the visual 'start' and 'finish' of the objects, blue tracks are lines drawn back to possible origin. Object number and time in video included. Scene frozen at 26 seconds into video when object 1 is seen (CCTV)

Tracks of seven objects during Chinese space walk. Red tracks are the visual 'start' and 'finish' of the objects, blue tracks are lines drawn back to possible origin. Object number and time in video included. Scene frozen at 26 seconds into video when object 1 is seen (CCTV)

China successfully launched three taikonauts into Earth orbit and, on September 27th, the first Chinese national (41 year old fighter pilot Zhai Zhigang) walked in space. The space walk lasted a total of 15 minutes, enough time to retrieve some solid lubricant from the outer hull of the Shenzhou-7 module and to give the brand new “Feitian” space suit a trial run. The launch, orbital insertion, space walk, re-entry and landing were all executed perfectly, securing China as only the third nation to successfully carry out an extra-vehicular activity (EVA).

It can therefore be expected, as with space flight achievements by the US and Russia before, there will be some conspiracy theories out there…

OK, Phil Plait over at Bad Astronomy beat me to the punch on this one, but I thought I’d contribute my 2c worth. First, let’s have a look at the video montage I used as a reference (primarily because this YouTube video had a “high quality” version):

At first I was more than a little intrigued by this video. After discussing this with Captain Jack over at Paranormal Radio in last week’s regular show on October 3rd (listen to the recording), I began to replay the video over and over to watch for the anomalies. Unfortunately the version I used (above), has some rather annoying commentary with it.

There have been a few websites now pointing the finger at this “faked” Chinese space walk, primarily anti-government websites (such as the Epoch Times, who provides no references to the “Chinese bloggers” they cite), plus pro-Taiwanese commenters. Of course there is a searing discontent toward China, after all this regime is responsible for human rights breaches, suppression of freedom and control of information. The western world has it’s problems, but at least we’re not controlled by the state (at least we think we’re not… are we?). Insofar as China’s efforts in space, they needed to be sure that they were 100% authentic and transparent with the world. Unfortunately, they were already fighting a losing battle even before the rocket launched.

A few hours before the launch of the Shenzhou spacecraft, the state-controlled news website Xinhuanet published an article documenting the successful orbital insertion of the three-man crew. A transcript of the future conversation between mission control and the Shenzhou 7 module appeared online due to a “technical error.” (A pretty big error if you ask me.) Even before the engines had ignited the conspiracy theories were on fire! And rightly so. Who’s to say this transcript wouldn’t have been issued regardless of mission success or failure? So, China was already on its back-foot, the launch was viewed with utmost suspicion.

Bubbles

Tracks of seven objects during Chinese space walk. Object number and time in video included (CCTV)

Tracks of seven objects during Chinese space walk. Object number and time in video included (CCTV)

After a whole evening devoted to scrutinizing floating Chinese astronauts, I’m convinced that the China space walk is authentic, although I’m not prepared to dismiss the conspiracy claims out of hand. Pretty much all of the claims can be explained easily (of which I’ll give a rundown later), but the one thing I have been intrigued by are the alleged “bubbles.”

The theory goes a little like this: In an effort to direct attention away from the baby milk scandal, China rushed the launch of the Long-March II-F rocket to bring their successful EVA forward by a few days. Alas, the Chinese authorities had no intention to send a costly mission into space. So, just like the faked visuals in the Beijing Olympics, they put together a Capricorn One-style faked space mission to wow the world.

So how did they do this? They shot the whole EVA in a massive water tank; the rotating Earth was pasted in by digital-visual experts. What do you get in water? Bubbles. And by the looks of things, there are plenty of bubbles in the video!

Actually, although I was curious at first (and I’ll explain why in a moment), those objects you see are not bubbles, it’s pieces of debris being released from inside the spaceship and from the activities of the taikonauts. If you have a look at the image above, I decided to trace the paths taken by our “bubbles” in an attempt to see where they originated. Although I was using the highly scientific method of pausing a YouTube video and hitting the “Prt Sc” button, I think I was able to capture seven “bubbles” pretty nicely. Then, using Photoshop (like that’s never been used in space-related propaganda before) I traced the track made by the “bubbles” (red line) and then traced its direction back to a possible origin (blue line) – all are straight lines. I would have liked to have captured more of these “bubbles” but even the “high quality” version of the video wasn’t great, so I had to make do with seven.

As pointed out by the anti-conspiracy theorists out there, bubbles tend to float upward. Well, this is true, but I was concerned that these “bubbles” could still be “bubbles” even though they look as if they are travelling in “random” directions. After all, if weightless conditions had been replicated in a huge water tank, why would it matter which way up the “mocked” spaceship was orientated? I was concerned that we may be looking at a full-scale mock-up of the Shenzhou-7 dangling down, or tilted, so the camera is at the top, looking toward the bottom of the tank. Therefore, any “bubbles” produced float upward, toward and then away from the camera. At first, this might give the impression the “bubbles” are travelling in random directions… but there would be a flaw to this plan…

The 2004 Perseid meteor shower - example of meteors originating from a common point, the radiant (© Fred Bruenjes)

The 2004 Perseid meteor shower - example of meteors originating from a common point, the radiant (© Fred Bruenjes)

If we are able to track the paths of each of the “bubbles”, given enough bubbles, we should see a statistical trend toward a radiant pattern, much like a meteor radiant (pictured left). After all, given enough travel time, all bubbles in a deep tank will float upward, in a straight-ish line, each tracing back to a more-or-less common radial point.

So what do we see? “Bubbles” numbered 1, 2, 4, 6 and 7 seem to appear from a common point.

Hah! Proof that these are bubbles!

Woah, hold on just a minute. There are another two “bubble tracks” that don’t follow this pattern. The renegade “bubbles” (numbered 3 and 5) seem to not fit this trend, plus they are travelling in straight lines, no curvature or turbulent behaviour to suggest they were being disturbed. For my theory to be correct, all the bubbles would need to be travelling from the same radial point. Unless they are being blown around by some underwater fan system; my radiant theory was getting weak.

So I looked back to the official explanation as to what these “bubbles” were: debris from inside the Shenzhou module were being released into space – the pressure gradient from inside (the capsule’s pressure will have been “equalized” with the vacuum of space, it wouldn’t be a perfect vacuum) to outside caused the fast velocities of the debris.

With this in mind, I looked to where “bubbles” 1, 2, 4, 6 and 7 came from. Tracing back along the blue lines, they do indeed originate from the open hatch. Still, they might have still been bubbles, but that didn’t explain “bubbles” 3 and 5. 3 and 5 originated from the activity of Zhai Zhigang during the EVA and appeared to fire away in completely different directions to the other five “bubbles”. Also, on reviewing each of the moving objects, they appear to very un-bubble-like shapes. Some look like tumbling pieces of ice or other flake-like pieces of debris.

Alas, there is one thing I cannot very explain convincingly. At 3:03 minutes into the video, you will notice a strange bubble-like object appear near Zhai’s visor. This is one of the key elements to the space walk conspiracy. It looks like a bubble has been released, it travels around the bulbous helmet and then released upwards (following line number 3 in my diagram), much like what you’d expect from a diver’s mask. I actually think this is a piece of debris travelling toward the camera, giving the impression it is an expanding bubble travelling upwards. There is probably a contributing reflection in the visor that makes it look as if the debris is travelling around the visor, when it is actually travelling on a linear path away from Zhai. I’ll leave that oddity for you to decide.

We must also remember, if this was shot in a massive tank of water, there would be a lot more bubbles in the water. Unless they were digitally removed (in which case, why leave the obvious seven bubbles for us all to see?), this definitely was not an underwater scene. Other underwater phenomena like turbulence, cavitation and nucleation are also not present.

Reflections of an array of studio lights

Two screenshots of the video. Left: The reflection in Zhai's visor shows a three-row array attached to the spacecraft. Right: The reflection from Zhai's wrist mirror shows the same array, only closer. They are not studio lights (CCTV)

Two screenshots of the video. Left: The reflection in Zhai's visor shows a three-row array attached to the spacecraft. Right: The reflection from Zhai's wrist mirror shows the same array, only closer. They are not studio lights (CCTV)

This is another “key” piece of evidence that the space walk was faked – the reflection in Zhai’s wrist mirror. The mirror is used by the taikonaut to see beyond his field of view; at the end of the day, it is hard to turn your head in a space helmet, so Zhai had to employ the use of a handy little mirror on his wrist.

But, if this scene was filmed underwater, in a studio, surely any reflective objects in the scene will pick out things like… I don’t know… studio lights? According to the theory, at 5:23 minutes into the video, a rapid wrist movement appears to flash three rows of a studio light array.

I’ll make this one quick and painless

Wind back the video to 1:18 minutes, when Zhai crawls out of the hatch. Look in his visor. There is a wide-angle view of the hull of the spaceship. What do you see? There is an obvious three-row array of some kind of lighting system or some other spaceship equipment. It is not studio lighting you can see in Zhai’s wrist reflection, it is a reflection of some equipment (possibly a small light array for the camera) attached to the hull. I cannot find the blueprints of the Shenzhou-7 module, but if I had to put money on it, I’d say the “studio lights” are in fact a small lighting system for the hull-mounted camera.

Alas, the Chinese DID get into orbit…

The main conspiracy theories are the “bubbles” proving this space walk was filmed in a water tank, and the reflection proving it was shot in a studio. For the reasons given above, neither are a possibility. There are also some other theories such as:

  • There are no stars. Correct, many orbital images and video do not contain stars. This is because the Earth is usually the brightest thing (by several orders of magnitude) in shot. If there is a bright object (i.e. a white spacesuit, or bright terrestrial clouds), the camera’s aperture will close down. This has the effect of removing any faint objects from the shot. Stars will blend in with the black of space so the details of the spacewalk and Earth’s globe can be seen. If the camera aperture were to be opened, the brightness of the Earth will appear “burned out”, appearing as a bright white blob. There are measures that can be taken to decrease the contrast with the background of space, thereby picking out the pinpoints of starlight, but streaming video from space isn’t typically of the highest quality, especially if the system is automated.
  • The flag looks funny. Actually it doesn’t. This is a classic piece of evidence for the Moon hoaxers, saying that the Apollo flags implanted in the lunar surface “wave” as if blown around. The same theory appears to be aired when Zhai enthusiastically waves his red Chinese flag around. Admittedly, the flag was probably made out of a stiffer material than fabric (to ensure the whole flag can be seen on camera, rather than folding into a useless knot), but there is no indication that this flag is waving underwater. It is waving an a vacuum, there’s no evidence to the contrary.

So, we are presented with two options. Either, China went into space and performed a flawless 15-minute EVA, or the mother of all space hoaxes has just been carried out. So which one do you think it is? I’m betting that China did indeed get into space. The “bubbles” are in fact space debris, the reflection of “studio lights” is in fact a reflection of some equipment on the Shenzhou-7 hull, and everything else is simply hard to believe.

Whether you like it or not, China is indeed the third country in history to carry out a successful space walk…

Historic spacewalks (from left-to-right): March 18th 1965, Russia - Alexei Leonov. June 3rd 1965, USA - Ed White. September 27th 2008, China - Zhai Zhigang.

Historic spacewalks (from left-to-right): March 18th 1965, Russia - Alexei Leonov. June 3rd 1965, USA - Ed White. September 27th 2008, China - Zhai Zhigang.

100 responses to “Bubbles, Reflections and Space Walks… Did China Really Fake It?

  1. Browsing on Google for something else closely connected, regardless before i ramble on too much i would just like to state how much I cherished your post, I've added your web blog and also obtained your Feed, Again thank you very much for the article carry on the good work.

  2. It's so tough to encounter right information on the blog. I realy loved reading this post. It has strengthen my faith more. You all do such a great job at such Concepts… can't tell you how much I, for one appreciate all you do!

  3. I really like this article,because i do think this will help us to prepare a sound project on this topic.I bookmarked the web site so in future i can search it for more article. PKR bonus codes Me and my friend were arguing about an issue similar to this! Now I know that I was right. lol! Thanks for the information you post.

  4. “The world is divided in to three classes of people: a very small group that makes things happen, a somewhat larger group that watches things happen, and the great multitude which never knows what happened.” –Nicholas Murray Butler, President of Columbia University, 1931 Nobel Peace Prize winner “Le monde se divise en trois catégories de gens: un très petit nombre qui fait se produire les évènements, un groupe un peu plus important qui veille à leur exécution et les regarde s'accomplir, et enfin une vaste majorité qui ne sait jamais ce qui s'est produit en réalité.”Nicholas Murray ButlerPrésident de la Pilgrim Society, membre de la Carnegie, membre du CFR (Council on Foreign Relations) allforthegreatergood.com/turn_the_page_3.htmlChina space program is fake like apollo moon (opération of propaganda).

  5. It’s amazing that Chinese have already launched space craft for their own space mission. Space exploration is a very expensive mission but they spent a lot of money for their own. That’s pretty good for them.

  6. NASA has indeed reached again another feat! A giant leap for science. I am amazed that they are representing mankind’s invention that would greatly help determine of what humans are capable of.
    Merry Christmas!
    Shaina

  7. Well, I think China really fake the space walks. I but I also think that they didn’t fake it. Gush I’m I think i’m crazy hehehe. Well, Thanks for this blog it makes me crazy.

  8. How I wish I could be on that suit. My dream was being an astronaut but turned out am not suited for it. Would just browse for this one here, you managed to capture the reflection cool. Every little thing on space is easily monitored and noticed by people on earth, fascinating.

  9. You hardly debunked anything, you halfwit. Go back and watch the China Space Walk Conspiracy theory video and tell me what you find… God, you and Plait are such FUCKING idiots.

  10. Screw the “bubbles”. Look at the teathers that anchor him to the craft. They float. No mater how he tries to push them down, they emediatly float back up. Unless they’re bunched up beneath him, or they’re stretched out, they float upwards every time. Just an observation. The shots from inside the craft look real to me. Outside, not so much. Maby something went wrong and they couldn’t complete the spacewalk. Maby it was a great success. Is anyone in China seeing this, or is it a completely banned topic? 

  11. All this makes me think it’s a bad idea to do stories about TaylorMade R7 TP Iron Set
    side characters to sell for 99 cents. First the 99 cents price point
    tends to bring in a LOT of cheapskates. No offense to anyone who truly
    can’t afford more for whatever unfortunate monetary reason, but… for the
    most part, the readership who pays 99 cents for ebooks is more trouble
    than they are worth to deal with. (And this isn’t just about books, this
    is true in ALL businesses. You get the most whining and complaining
    from people who spend the least amount of money for things. I have no
    idea why. It’s why business owners are advised to create a premium
    product or cultivate a premium customer base and stop doing business
    with cheap people who ask for too much for the Canada Goose
    price they pay.)

    When Kept was 99 cents people bitched left and right about how it was
    too short and it should have been free. (I would have this problem in
    spades with a 10k story, since it would be half the length of Kept). As
    soon as it went to $2.99, the complaining stopped, because it pushed my
    book off the radar of that kind of reader. I don’t WANT that kind of
    reader. Again, no offense. But I work hard, and I just don’t want to
    mess with people who feel like I should be cheap canada goose entertaining them for free like their writing butt monkey.

  12. The excellent replica
    oakley sunglasses article assited fake oakley sunglasses me very much! oakley sunglasses fake It’s really give me a big oakley sunglasses replica help,thanks much.

  13. Every single woman within the earth has applied makeup to a point in time. It functions as an excellent tool to heighten our beauty. Applying cosmetics not demand for our self-respect too. As such, wholesale mac make up no wonder that the cosmetic industry is having such a big increment.

    We all like to purchase cosmetics like wholesale lip gloss for casual objective as mascaras, eyeliners, lipsticks, wholesale lip gloss, blush, foundation, scents, hair styling gels and compact to list several. As some, it has a really low monetary value to purchase all these. Purchase of wholesale cosmetics wholesale mac makeup can volunteer a superb answer simply because it combines each lineaments of affordability and character essential that each woman looks for in all of the item.

    You will find plenty of wholesale providers named site therapy cosmetics. So if we want to purchase them for our everyday practice or want to bargain them in bulk for occupation functions then websites like wholesale mac cosmetics Salehoo can aid us in searching for a honest supplier. Wholesale costs of these cosmetics are genuinely fair and we need to have to survey prior to opting various providers offers really low-cost prices.

  14. I am so happy to read this. This is the type of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that’s at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this greatest doc.

  15.  http://www.coachbagsforsale.net    

    http://www.thecoachpurses.org

    http://www.blog.thecoachpurses.org  

    http://www.blog.coachwiki.net

    http://www.onlinestore.coachbagsoutlet.org

    http://www.coachwiki.net

    http://www.blog.coachbagsforsale.net

    http://www.thecoachoutlet.org

    http://www.handbags.thecoachpurses.org

    http://www.coach.coachwiki.net

    http://www.coach.coachbagsoutlet.org

    http://www.outlet.coachbagsforsale.net

    http://www.cheapbags.thecoachoutlet.org

    http://www.coachbagsoutlet.org

    http://www.coachbags.topbagonline.com

    http://www.pickmyheels.com

    http://www.pickushoes.com

    http://www.buyshoes.pickmyheels.com

    http://www.clsale.christianlouboutinschuhesale.com

    http://www.christianlouboutinschuhesale.com

    http://www.blog.christianlouboutinschuhesale.com

    http://www.highheels.manoloblahnikshop.net

    http://www.thesunglasses.org

    http://www.blog.thesunglasses.org

    http://www.coach.thesunglasses.org

    http://www.cheapshoes.toryburchshoesale.org

    http://www.toryburchshoesale.org

    http://www.blog.toryburchshoesale.org

    http://www.heels.themanoloblahnik.com

    http://www.blog.manoloblahnikshop.net

    http://www.manoloblahnikshop.net

    http://www.blog.thepandorabracelet.com

    http://www.store.thepandorajewelry.org

    http://www.thepandorabracelet.com

    http://www.pandora.thepandorabracelet.com

    http://www.blog.thepandorajewelry.org

    http://www.highheels.pickmyheels.com

    http://www.chaussuresnikeshox.com

    http://www.blog.chaussuresnikeshox.com

    http://www.blog.thejumpman23.com

    http://www.thejumpman23.com

    http://www.blog.jumpman123.net

    http://www.jordan.chaussuresnikeshox.com

    http://www.jordan.pickushoes.com

    http://www.jordanshoes.jumpman123.net

    http://www.jordan.thejumpman23.com

    http://www.cheapuggs.theuggsoutlets.com

    http://www.theuggsoutlets.com

    http://www.theuggsoutlet.org

    http://www.online.theuggsoutlet.org

    http://www.blog.theuggsoutlets.com

    http://www.blog.theuggsoutlet.org

    http://www.ugg.shoesonlinestores.org

    http://www.uggs.emusheepskinbootsale.com

    http://www.buyshoes.emusheepskinbootsale.com

    http://www.emusheepskinbootsale.com

    http://www.blog.shoesonlinestores.org

    http://www.thegolfs.org

    http://www.boots.thegolfs.org

    http://www.timberlandbootsmall.com

    http://www.timberlandbootsoutlet.org

    http://www.blog.timberlandbootsmall.com

    http://www.cheapboots.timberlandbootsoutlet.org

    http://www.timberland.thegolfs.org

    http://www.moncleroutletonline.org

    http://www.jackemoncler.moncleroutletonline.org

    http://www.vest.monclerjackenonline.org

    http://www.blog.timberlandbootsoutlet.org

    http://www.jacket.moncleroutletonline.org

    http://www.blog.monclerjackenonline.org

    http://www.blog.thecheapgucci.com

    http://www.gucci.topbagonline.com

    http://www.gucci.thecoachoutlet.org

    http://www.handbags.thecheapgucci.com

    http://soulinfo.org/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07        Women Franklin Marshall
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07       Women Franklin Marshall
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07       Women Franklin Marshall
    http://www.datingest.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07       Women Franklin Marshall
    http://jtwayne.net/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07        Women Franklin Marshall
    http://layoffsupportnetwork.com/lsn/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-        Women Franklin Marshall
    http://www.aura2aura.co.uk/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-         Women Franklin Marshall
    http://www.singlefling.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07       Women Franklin Marshall
    http://jeepstreet.com/DolJS/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07      Women Franklin Marshall
    http://gethott.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07        Women Franklin Marshall
    http://187mafia.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-07       Women Franklin Marshall
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07       franklin and marshal
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07       franklin and marshal
    http://www.datingest.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07       franklin and marshal
    http://jtwayne.net/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07       franklin and marshal
    http://layoffsupportnetwork.com/lsn/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07       franklin and marshal
    http://www.aura2aura.co.uk/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-       franklin and marshal
    http://www.singlefling.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07      franklin and marshal
    http://linkepm.com/epm/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07        franklin and marshal
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07        franklin and marshal
    http://187mafia.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07       franklin and marshal
    http://soulinfo.org/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07       franklin and marshal
    http://jeepstreet.com/DolJS/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshal-2011-10-07        franklin and marshal
    http://www.earthnewsnet.com/community/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-07       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.abandonaelsofa.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-08        ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.findadatefortonight.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-07       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.itsocials.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-07       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://fortalezamia.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-07       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://askmilton.com/community1/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-07       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-08-0         ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.xzooom.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.we-love-israel.net/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-08-0        ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.sendmeorg.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://liveparanormal.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt       ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.geekissingle.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt        ranklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.abandonaelsofa.com/blogs/entry/Franklin-Marshall-Sets-2011-10-08       Franklin Marshall Sets
    http://www.findadatefortonight.com/blogs/entry/Franklin-Marshall-Sets-2011-10-07       Franklin Marshall Sets
    http://www.itsocials.com/blogs/entry/Franklin-Marshall-Sets       Franklin Marshall Sets
    http://fortalezamia.com/blogs/entry/Franklin-Marshall-Sets-2011-10-07       Franklin Marshall Sets
    http://askmilton.com/community1/blogs/entry/Franklin-Marshall-Sets-2011-10-07       Franklin Marshall Sets
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/Franklin-Marshall-Sets-2011-10-08-0      Franklin Marshall Sets

  16. http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-2011-10-12   moncler deutschland
    http://entertainmentartists.net/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-2011-10-12      moncler deutschland
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-2011-10-12       moncler deutschland
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-2011-10-12    moncler deutschland
    http://www.gamerdating.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-2011-10-12   moncler deutschland
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-12      Discount  moncler
    http://entertainmentartists.net/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-12      Discount  moncler
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-12  Discount  moncler
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-12       Discount  moncler
    http://www.gamerdating.com/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-12       Discount  moncler
    http://www.gamerdating.com/blogs/entry/moncler-outlet-store-2011-10-12-0       moncler outlet store
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/moncler-outlet-store-2011-10-12-0     moncler outlet store
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/moncler-outlet-store-2011-10-12-0       moncler outlet store
    http://entertainmentartists.net/blogs/entry/moncler-outlet-store-2011-10-12-0     moncler outlet store
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/moncler-outlet-store-2011-10-12-0        moncler outlet store
    http://www.gamerdating.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-2011-10-12-0     moncler  deutschland
    http://entertainmentartists.net/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-2011-10-12-0      moncler  deutschland
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-2011-10-12-0       moncler  deutschland
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet        Headphone Outlet
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet-2011-10-11        Headphone Outlet
    http://ripplusa.com/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet-2011-10-11        Headphone Outlet
    http://www.earthnewsnet.com/community/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet-2011-10-11      Headphone Outlet
    http://fortalezamia.com/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet-2011-10-11        Headphone Outlet
    http://formmyband.com/m/events/view/Headphone-Outlet-2011-10-11      Headphone Outlet
    http://glamorousladies.de/Community/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet        Headphone Outlet
    http://hook2it.com/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet-2011-10-11        Headphone Outlet
    http://askmilton.com/community1/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet-2011-10-11       Headphone Outlet
    http://www.exfling.com/community/blogs/entry/Headphone-Outlet-2011-10-11       Headphone Outlet
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car      monster ipod car
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car       monster ipod car
    http://ripplusa.com/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car-2011-10-11       monster ipod car
    http://www.earthnewsnet.com/community/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car-       monster ipod car
    http://fortalezamia.com/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car-2011-10-11      monster ipod car
    http://formmyband.com/m/events/view/monster-ipod-car-2011-10-11      monster ipod car
    http://glamorousladies.de/Community/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car-2011-10-12       monster ipod car
    http://hook2it.com/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car-2011-10-11       monster ipod car
    http://askmilton.com/community1/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car-2011-10-11      monster ipod car
    http://www.exfling.com/community/blogs/entry/monster-ipod-car-      monster ipod car
    http://homehealth360.com/modules/boonex/blogs/blogs.php?action=show_member_post&post_id=1348     monster ipod car
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/Discount-Monster      Discount Monster
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/Discount-Monster       Discount Monster
    http://ripplusa.com/blogs/entry/Discount-Monster       Discount Monster
    http://www.earthnewsnet.com/community/blogs/entry/Discount-Monster-       Discount Monster
    http://fortalezamia.com/blogs/entry/Discount-Monster       Discount Monster
    http://glamorousladies.de/Community/blogs/entry/Discount-Monster        Discount Monster
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-12       Women Franklin Marshall
    http://liveparanormal.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-11       Women Franklin Marshall
    http://www.we-love-israel.net/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-11      Women Franklin Marshall
    http://www.geekissingle.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-11     Women Franklin Marshall
    http://www.sendmeorg.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-11     Women Franklin Marshall
    http://www.xzooom.com/blogs/entry/Women-Franklin-Marshall-2011-10-11        Women Franklin Marshall
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-sweatshirt-2011-10-12      franklin and marshall sweatshirt
    http://liveparanormal.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-sweatshirt-2011-10-11      franklin and marshall sweatshirt
    http://www.we-love-israel.net/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-sweatshirt-2011-10-11      franklin and marshall sweatshirt
    http://www.geekissingle.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-sweatshirt-2011-10-11     franklin and marshall sweatshirt
    http://www.xzooom.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-sweatshirt-2011-10-11      franklin and marshall sweatshirt
    http://www.sendmeorg.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-sweatshirt-2011-10-11       franklin and marshall sweatshirt
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-polo-2011-10-12       franklin marshall polo
    http://liveparanormal.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-polo-2011-10-11       franklin marshall polo
    http://www.we-love-israel.net/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-polo-       franklin marshall polo
    http://www.geekissingle.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-polo-2011-10-11       franklin marshall polo
    http://fortalezamia.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-outlet-2011-10-11      moncler deutschland outlet
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-outlet-2011-10-12      moncler deutschland outlet
    http://www.we-love-israel.net/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-outlet      moncler deutschland outlet
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-outlet-2011-10-12      moncler deutschland outlet
    http://liveparanormal.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-outlet     moncler deutschland outlet
    http://www.geekissingle.com/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-outlet      moncler deutschland outlet
    http://jeepstreet.com/DolJS/blogs/entry/moncler-deutschland-outlet-2011-10-11    moncler deutschland outlet
    http://gstroop499.com/events/entry/moncler-deutschland-outlet-2011-10-11       moncler deutschland outlet
    http://fortalezamia.com/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-11      Discount moncler
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-12       Discount moncler
    http://www.we-love-israel.net/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler      Discount moncler
    http://chinahere.net/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-12     Discount moncler
    http://liveparanormal.com/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler      Discount moncler
    http://www.geekissingle.com/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler      Discount moncler
    http://jeepstreet.com/DolJS/blogs/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-11     Discount moncler
    http://gstroop499.com/events/entry/Discount-moncler-2011-10-11    Discount moncler
    http://whitneyworld.mobi/whitneycenter/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-11         shop moncler
    http://entertainmentartists.net/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-11        shop moncler
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12        shop moncler
    http://www.gamerdating.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12        shop moncler
    http://linkepm.com/epm/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-11        shop moncler
    http://www.worldtopdjs.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-11       shop moncler
    http://www.datingest.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12         shop moncler
    http://jtwayne.net/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12        shop moncler
    http://www.zaboink.net/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-11      shop moncler
    http://www.singlefling.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12       shop moncler
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-11       shop moncler
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler       shop moncler
    http://layoffsupportnetwork.com/lsn/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12       shop moncler
    http://whitneyworld.mobi/whitneycenter/blogs/entry/Discount-moncle       Discount moncle   
    http://entertainmentartists.net/blogs/entry/Moncler-Womens-Jackets      Moncler Womens Jackets
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/Moncler-Womens-Jackets-2011-10-12       Moncler Womens Jackets
    http://www.gamerdating.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12-0      shop moncler
    http://linkepm.com/epm/events/entry/shop-moncler      shop moncler
    http://www.worldtopdjs.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-11-0     shop moncler
    http://www.datingest.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12-0      shop moncler
    http://jtwayne.net/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12-0      shop moncler
    http://www.zaboink.net/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12      shop moncler
    http://www.singlefling.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12-0      shop moncler
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12     shop moncler
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-11      shop moncler
    http://layoffsupportnetwork.com/lsn/blogs/entry/shop-moncler-2011-10-12-0       shop moncler
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12      franklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.datingest.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12      franklin marshall T shirt
    http://jtwayne.net/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12     franklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.aura2aura.co.uk/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12     franklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.singlefling.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12     franklin marshall T shirt
    http://jeepstreet.com/DolJS/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12-0     franklin marshall T shirt
    http://linkepm.com/epm/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12     franklin marshall T shirt
    http://abtv1.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12     franklin marshall T shirt
    http://gethott.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12       franklin marshall T shirt
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/franklin-marshall-T-shirt-2011-10-12      franklin marshall T shirt
    http://www.eroticandsensual.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12     franklin and marshall cheap
    http://www.datingest.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12       franklin and marshall cheap
    http://jtwayne.net/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12       franklin and marshall cheap
    http://www.aura2aura.co.uk/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12       franklin and marshall cheap
    http://www.singlefling.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12      franklin and marshall cheap
    http://jeepstreet.com/DolJS/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12      franklin and marshall cheap
    http://linkepm.com/epm/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12      franklin and marshall cheap
    http://layoffsupportnetwork.com/lsn/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12       franklin and marshall cheap
    http://zk.zainabkamran.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap        franklin and marshall cheap
    http://gethott.com/blogs/entry/franklin-and-marshall-cheap-2011-10-12        franklin and marshall cheap
     

  17. moncler
    moncler
    jackets
    moncler
    outlet
    moncler
    jacket
    moncler
    sale
    moncler jackets
    sale
    cheap moncler
    jackets
    moncler jacket
    sale
    moncler
    vest
    moncler vest
    sale
    moncler
    coats sale
    moncler
    coats on sale
    buy
    moncler coats
    cheap
    moncler coats
    moncler
    coats
    moncler online
    shop
    moncler
    online
    cheap
    moncler
    moncler jackets on
    sale
    moncler
    shop
    moncler on
    sale
    discount
    moncler
    moncler jackets
    outlet
    moncler
    sales
    moncler
    discount
    buy
    moncler
    buy moncler
    jackets
    discount moncler
    online
    discount moncler
    jackets
    outlet
    moncler
    buy moncler
    online
    moncler for
    sale
    cheap moncler
    jacket
    xzq 

  18. We always look for something can’t reach, the north face outlet walk around the real truth and can’t achieve the goals we expect, cheap north face
    therefore, we still not know how to get it, do it and make it.Thanks for adding this North face store site to one of the many useful sites covering this topic on the net, its successful in its own right and I’ll  definitely be coming back.This is awesome, please keep writing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s